Phineas Gage

I'm almost finished with this short (86 pages) book about the life of a man who had a 3 foot iron tamping rod rammed through his skull in a freak accident that changed his life and taught us some things about how the brain works.

If I were to pick a single book to have everyone in my science classes read, it would be this one. Short enough to get through in a brief amount of time, interesting, engaging, detailed information presented in small chunks, and the main story, which is quite compelling, can be followed even if some of the details are a little too advanced for most students. A great accompaniment to a nervous system unit.

Phineas's accident left him "physically" unharmed - he could still function physically as well as he did before the accident. He remained strong, fit, lost no coordination or physical abilities that could be detected. His memory was intact, as well as his mathematical reasoning ability and attention span. However, Phineas was no longer his old self. The iron rod tore through his frontal lobe destroying an area of the brain that is today associated with "sociability" - the capacity to interact with others by reading and responding appropriately to their verbal and nonverbal cues as well as the overall social context in which these interactions take place. Here's a quote:

Humans have always argued about what makes us human. Is it our ability to walk on two feet? To hold tools in our hands? To speak and hear language? To worship a supreme being? The case of Phineas Gage suggests that we are human because our frontal lobes are set up so that we can get along with other humans. we are "hard-wired" to be sociable. When we lose that ability, we end up like Phineas.

I'm not sure the answer actually follows - there are plenty of social animals who are "hard-wired" to get along with other members of their own species. The question itself is probably moot. There is no single quality we possess that other animals do not. It becomes a matter of degree and the unique combination of characteristics we exhibit. The book raises a number of interesting questions that bridge science, philosophy, and psychology. Just the kind of ideas I like to discuss with my students.

Image Source (Wikipedia)